Hello dear
Welcome To Papa Jay's Pizzeria
Located in the heart of Dover, NH, Papa Jay's Pizzeria offers an unforgettable culinary experience for pizza lovers. Renowned for their excellent double pepperoni pizza, garlic parmesan wings, and crispy potato skins, this pizzeria stands out for its Boston Italian-style pizza, featuring a perfect crust and just the right amount of cheese and grease. Patrons rave about the prompt, friendly service, with staff who remember special requests, making each visit feel personalized. With reasonable prices and a commitment to quality, Papa Jay's is a must-try spot that delivers solid food and a welcoming atmosphere for all.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
About
Papa Jay's Pizzeria
Welcome to Papa Jay's Pizzeria, a hidden gem nestled at 18 Broadway in Dover, NH. This charming pizzeria delights locals and visitors alike with its authentic Boston Italian-style pizza and a variety of mouthwatering dishes that ensure a satisfying dining experience.
One of the standout offerings here is the double pepperoni pizza, lauded by enthusiastic patrons like Kassy D. The rich, savory flavors of the pepperoni paired with a perfectly baked crust create a symphony of taste with every bite. The pizza is baked to perfection, yielding just the right amount of grease and a light cheese that promises not to overwhelm the palate. Daniel Macduff applauds the solid food and service, characterizing it as “tremendous” and emphasizing that it’s well worth checking out.
Additionally, the garlic parmesan wings and potato skins are also notable highlights on the menu. These dishes showcase the restaurant's commitment to quality, flavor, and customer satisfaction. Cindy Hall, a loyal customer, appreciates the team's attentiveness and quick service even during busy periods, making it a reliable choice for anyone looking to enjoy a hearty meal without breaking the bank.
At Papa Jay's, the customer service is just as commendable as the food. Ted S. highlights the courteous staff who are always eager to accommodate special requests, ensuring that each dining experience is tailor-made to your liking. The welcoming atmosphere fostered by the owner and employees contributes significantly to the charm of this pizzeria.
For those looking for the quintessential pizza experience, Papa Jay's Pizzeria knocks it out of the park with their dedication to quality ingredients and customer care. Dennis C. expresses the joy of discovering this spot, relishing in a couple of slices and a beer — a simple yet fulfilling pleasure.
In summary, whether you’re craving a classic slice or adventurous toppings, Papa Jay’s Pizzeria has crafted an inviting menu that delights and surprises. From its excellent pizzas to friendly service, it’s a slice of enjoyment waiting to be savored. Call +1 603-750-7272 today to place your order and dive into the delicious offerings at Papa Jay's!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Excellent double pepperoni pizza, garlic parm wings, and potato skins. ”
“ Always accurate with my order They remember my special request and polite ad accommodating very quick even when busy ! Reasonably Priced even with others increasing at enormous rates thanks great team always friendly if any problem they take care of You promptly but I’ve had none I’m An adult lol ”
“ I’ve just been getting delivery from here for a short time, however I felt the need to compliment them. Food, service is solid and certainly worth checking out! Tremendous.. ”
“ Very good pizza, perfect crust, pepperoni and sauce. Perfect amount of grease , nice light cheese, not too chewy. Very nice owner / employees. Very courteous and always happy to accommodate special requests. ”
“ If you like boston Italian style pizza, this knocks it out of the park. Glad we stopped in for a couple slices and a beer. Delish. ”
“ Wow! Online ordered food delivery service for our Fall Cleanup crew. Bread was fresh & soft, filling was still hot (wrapped in foil) and beverages were enjoyed by all. ---- snip ---- Enjoyed a large steak bomb & onion rings. Very good. Today, the place is hopping with telephone orders, drivers & in store pickup. Give the menu a try. ”
“ I ordered the two for 26 one topping pizza and a chefs salad. Realized I was a bit short on cash. To my horror I realized I wouldn’t be able to give a good tip. I immediately called and canceled my salad and told them why said sorry it was an honest mistake. They not only didn’t make me feel bad about it they turned around and made me the salad anyways. Our food is hot it’s fresh and it’s delicious. Papa jays is the best! ”
“ Probably the best cheese pizza I've ever had. Thin crust, not greasy and slightly sweet. ”